Starting pitcher Nestor Cortes was the centerpiece of the Milwaukee Brewers‘ return haul from trading co-closer Devin Williams to the Yankees last December. Eight months later, Cortes is a member of the Padres, logging all of two starts in Milwaukee before injuries sapped his season. Over in New York, Williams lost his closer’s job, got it back, and has had one good month en route to a 5.04 ERA.
Without the other part of Milwaukee’s incoming package, then minor-league third baseman Caleb Durbin, the trade would look at this juncture like a lose-lose scenario. Thanks to Durbin, it’s been anything but for the Brewers.
Caleb Durbin is Milwaukee Brewers’ diamond in the rough
Durbin didn’t make the spring training cut. Instead, the Brewers went with fellow rookie Oliver Dunn as the team’s starting third baseman. Durbin went down to Triple-A Nashville.
Dunn didn’t last. After he struggled through the first three weeks of the season, he and Durbin switched places and the latter hasn’t squandered his shot.
Following a slow start, he’s turned up the heat at the dish while playing outstanding defense. He’s had an OPS around .800 for over two months now and has his season slashline up to .263/.344/.372. His 2.2 WAR in 86 games played is tied for 10th among all third basemen, making him one of the position’s more valuable players.
The Brewers saw plenty of promise in Durbin when they traded for him, coming off a strong season with New York’s Triple-A affiliate. Even though he didn’t, he was a decent candidate to make the team out of spring.
The team likely didn’t see a legitimate Rookie of the Year candidate, which he is. By WAR, he and Braves catcher Drake Baldwin have contributed the same value to their teams, more than any other NL rookies.
Cortes, on the other hand, was supposed to be a consistent cog in the rotation. Last year for the Yankees, he made 30 starts and recorded a 3.77 ERA. Instead, he’s still making his way back from injury ahead of start number three this season. In San Diego.
Of course, Milwaukee did turn him into outfielder Brandon Lockridge, who will provide depth while Jackson Chourio is hurt. To dump Cortes’ salary, however, they had to attach a prospect, infielder Jorge Quintana.
Neither Cortes nor Williams has been what the receiving team hoped. Both will be free agents this offseason. Only the Yankees, however, are at risk of walking away empty-handed.
With years of team control remaining, the Brewers have in Durbin what looks to be their third baseman of both the present and future. The trade didn’t deliver according to expectations, but it’s hard to be too upset with the results.
For More Great Wisconsin Content
Follow me on X at @ezsniper14 and follow us @WiSportsHeroics for more great content. To read more of our articles and keep up to date on the latest in Wisconsin sports, click here!
1 Comment
Good opinion piece..
I was surprised Durbin didn’t make the team to begin with, but Capra and Dunn had great springs, so I wasn’t shocked.
Murphy has history with Durbin, so I suspect he was rewarding the other two to give them a shot before turning to Durbin.
Clubhouse balance is important and Murphy handled it well. His reward is Durbin is playing with purpose and even though I wanted a power bat for 3rd, Vaughn’s success has made the power side less of an issue. What impressed me about Durbin is his adapting defensively. His glove is solid and we all heard Durbins arm is more suited to second base. But he has done the most with what he has. He has perfected the skip bounce to first on balls hit to his right. It lands far enough from first that its easy for Vaughn to field..The other thing getting overlooked is how agile Vaughn is at first. He’s better than Hoskins and makes Bauers unnecessary.
I think that Black becomes a better option for the bench. He’s played a lot of OF in Nashville and even if he is best suited to DH, he can fill in at 3rd and 1st also.. Yeli still looks good in left while Frelick and Chourio heal. So things are looking good!